The coffin (observation
−3 5 Votes
Rate it:
By chirpey1987
- The coffin (observation
- Created: Mar 23, 2008
- Last updated: Aug 14, 2008
- After episode: 3.22: Through The Looking Glass
- Status: Current
- Flag this theory:
Hi all this is the first time that ive posted a theory so everyone bear with me here,
Iv’e just watched the last episode of series 3 when jack attends a funeral and there is nobody else there.
He looks surprised and hurt that nobody else attended. Also when the funeral guy ask him if he is friend or family he say “EITHER” not neither i have just watched it back like 200 times and jack defo says either everybody has been posting theories saying he say’s neither its not its EITHER.
I am not being trollish as i am a true addicted fan of lost, i just think thats what it sounds like and for my english i am from england. You can say either like in way thats like yeah either i don’t no god you guys are harsh
Key episodes
| # | Title | Aired | Central character | Theories |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.2 | Adrift | 9-28-2005 | Walt | 80 |
Sorry, but he definitely says “neither.” Check out the transcript of the episode on lostpedia if you don’t believe it.
http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/ThroughtheLookingGlasstranscript
He says neither. It makes no sense for him to say “either’. It is barely proper english. Why not just say “both”?
it dosen’t it says either and it is correct english check the dictionary don’t linch me listen for yourself
I just listened. He says “neither”.
The funeral director asked “friend or family”. So it was either a friend, a family member, or neither. Jacks answer was neither indicating the person was not a friend or a family member. What would an answer of “either” indicate? That the person was both a family member and a friend? Then why not answer “both”? Just check the transcript.
Why would he say “Either”. I hope you’re just trolling. Why would anyone in the world who knew an ounce of english say “either” to that question? IF anything, he would say “both”. This observation fails.
well.. i really dont think that matters…. what does matter is that they want us to think its michael… which is why i dont think it is. BUT if it were Michael, he is now off the island, testing if it will now let him die, puts the gun to his head and pulls the trigger, this time it works.
stick to liquor, you’re better at it.
note to self. Never argue correct grammar and include the phrase “linch me” Also, remember to use spell check to verify that the proper spelling is “lynch”
Watch with closed captioning and he definitly says “neither”
I have to say my partner and I had this same argument, I thought he said “either” too. I replayed it a million times and was stuck on hearing “either” but then watched it again a later time and it was definitely “neither”
I dont think it would be bad english to say either, far from it, and its like when you mis-hear song lyrics and then thats all you can hear lol
thanks jax