i don’t know why that picture went on twice

1st place - the locke, jacob and ben cabin scene.

2nd - kate and sawyer, cage sex scene in “i do”.

3rd - sawyer telling jack about his dad in australia.

there ares probably loads more that i just cant think of right now.

yeh sawyer telling jack was good i forgot about that 1

also, in joint 3rd place, charlies death. i loved charlie but it was such a heroic death, and i just loved the fact that he wrote “not pennys boat” on his hand, and desmonds reaction to it was great.

I don’t think he even need to die i just can’t understand why he shut the door.

Chirpey, I have no order for some of my favourite Lost moments, however I do think Charlie giving the ring to Aaron, and his favourite hits, were real tearjerkers.

I loved Hurley getting the Dharma van started, Sawyer clinking the Dharma beer can against the skeleton head of Roger, and pretty much anything Sawyer says to Hurley. Hurley saving the day in S3 finale was cool too.

Most dramatic moment for me, was Sawyer killing Cooper. And, I really like seeing Ben have the crap kicked out of him!

lol i guess u r not a big fan of benny boy lol

dab - totally agree about sawyer killing cooper. i forgot about that one! that was a breakthrough for sawyers character, and now he can move on, maiking that scene extremely important!

Chirpey, I have the utmost respect for Ben, and his abilities. However, I do like to see Ben get some of his own, on occasion. lol

Belle, I feel Sawyer did make a breakthrough when he killed Cooper. Although I did hate Locke for making him do it, at the time.

dab - yeah, it was pretty low of locke to get sawyer to do his dirty work!

how did locke even know about sawyers connection to cooper?

erm didn’t richard alpert say something to him i am not positive though

1. The first time Sawyer and Kate kiss; season 1

2. Charlie’s top ten list; season 3. What happened to this list? Last thing I remember, Charlie stuffed it in Desmond’s pocket. Then Desmond dove into the water. Was it destroyed?

3. Desmond speaks to Penny on Christmas Eve 2004; season 4.

alice - yeah, des and penny on the phone! definately should be in my top 3. i should rethink my top 3 list, there is too many favourite lost moments!

and yeah, it probably got destroyed. well logically it should have anyway, since it would have got wet, but it will probably pop up sooner or later anyway, maybe in a claire or des episode.

yeh the list and penny and des fone call i think i need a top 100

Chirpey, Boy it is hard to pick my favorite three, there are so many, but I think my most favorite so far has to be Alice1’s number three choice!

1) cage sex

2) sawyer cuddling Kate after she and Locke get into it

3) microbus takes out Tom

sex and violence, perhaps I should see a counselor.

Penny and des on the phone~i cried! Sawyer cheersing the skeleton head and Sawyer teaching jin how to talk to women in english.”those pants don’t make you look fat” lol

1) Sawyer telling Jack about his Dad. First time either character had let their guard down in front of each other.

2) Jack screaming at Kate to run down the walkie talkie

3) Sawyer shooting Tom after saying “this is for taking the kid off the raft”. We all must remember how shocked and angry we felt when we first saw Season 1 finale and it was good to see Sawyer hadn’t forgotten.

Oh yea and when jack tells Kate he loves her. Can’t help it, I want those two together SO bad!

I like this thread even if it’s not a theory!!!

1) Jack and Kates kiss

2) Sawyers saying ‘I couldn’t help myself you looked so darn cute holding that pickaxe!’

3) Jack and Sarah when she realises the op was a success

Let me preface this with: I am a girl and I love cheesy sappy love stuff. Okay? sigh Here goes:

3) Penny and Des phone call. I want nothing more in the show (now that Charlie is dead) than for those two to get back together. I love the love that they have for eachother, though it is strewn with tragedy.

2) I know lots have said this, but the top 10 list that Char put together. That entire episode is my favorite - the whole thing. Charlie was my favorite character and I really liked he and Claire together.

1) All time favorite scene, though it is a really short one, when Charlie meets Claire on the beach:

Charlie - “Your first plane crash?”

Claire - “How can you tell?”

Charlie - “Oh, you can always spot the noobies.”

I fell in love with Charlie in that scene. sigh

Ok so those are my top three but why not lay out a few more right?

Hurley on the beach with his CD player with a good island song playing as the episode was wrapping up.

The kiss between Hurley and Libby on the cliff. I like Hurley and was glad he got a little action. He deserves it.

When Sun and Jin reunite/make up after he was gone for so long. Raft, caught by the others. This is where I was happy about their love. He was such a jerk before!! Haha.

The fake peanut butter scene with Charlie and Claire. It was really touching and (again) I fell in love with Charlie. How very sweet.

Finally, I like the scene where Michael and Walt drive off on the boat because I dont like Michael and I was glad that we had a little break from hearing him say “Waaaalt!!” I wish he would go away completely!!

1. When they first go into the swan. I get goosebumps every time i watch it.

Best scenes..anything to do with Smokey. Smokey smashing Eko, Smokey after Kate and Juliet, Smokey trying to drag Locke down the hole, Smokey grabbing the pilot, etc.

1. Opening scene of “A Tale of Two Cities”, where we are introduced to Juliet for the first time (in the mirror primping for book club) and see the entirety of the crash of Oceanic Flight 815 from the perspective of the Others.

2. Nicci & Paulo betraying each another in a pointless feud over stolen diamonds that had no meaning on the island which led to their ironic death….

3. Every single second that Sawyer & Kate where being held in the cages….for various reasons….lol

blonde - “Every single second that Sawyer & Kate where being held in the cages….for various reasons….lol”

lol, yeah ditto. i loved those scenes too.

belle- you & I are always on the same page…lol…I am glad to have you here. XXXOOO

blonde - back at ya! xx

1) The final scene of the season 3 finale when it shows Jack and Kate together at the airport. Those of us who avoided spoilers all gave a collective “HOLY SH*T!! IT’S A flashforward!!!” (I can’t believe nobody else said this moment).

2) Desmond and Penny on the phone in The Constant.

3) Finding out who Nicki and Paulo really are in their centric episode “Expose”……. just kidding. I can’t think of a third favorite right now but it’s definitely not that.

The best scene had to be Kate and Sawyer in the cage and that’s in spite of how nasty they must of been.

1) Back to season 1 where the producers cleverly overlapped Boone’s death with Aaron’s birth. My emotions were all over the place here and didn’t know whether to be happy/sad/??? Very powerful stuff.

2) I’m with Irocz28 on his No.1 moment. The FF at the end of Season 3 was mind-blowing…’Kate. We have to go back…..’ This p*ssed us all off for 9 months or so and got everyone talking about the roaming possibilities. Slipping in the coffin scene too at the ‘hoffs drawlar’ (Anagram: Flash Forward) funeral parlour was also particularly clever.

3) When we get our 1st look down the hatch and discover that it has an inhabitant(desmond) as well as food supplies, beds, a mystery computer, showers etc. This posed the question to us all - ‘what the hell is going on here?!?

There are however many many more fav moments - great thread.